In Loving Memory of
Miranda Deanna
Finn
May 20, 1995
January 25, 2006

LAKE BUTLER, Fla (AP) - A truck driver who plowed into a car at a school bus stop last week killing seven children had been awake for 34 hours, except for a short nap, an investigator with the National Transportation Safety Board said Friday.

David Rayburn, the lead investigator for the Lake Butler crash, said the 31-year-old truck driver, Alvin Wilkerson, was refusing to talk to investigators about the accident.

"His attorney doesn't want him talking," Rayburn said.

Rayburn and Florida Highway Patrol Lt. Bill Leeper refused to release the attorney's name.

Jack Peetz, executive vice president and chief operating officer for Crete Carrier Corp. of Lincoln, Neb., the trucking company Wilkerson drove for, issued a statement Friday afternoon.

"As the National Transportation Safety Board announced, its statements today were preliminary and its investigation will be on-going.  Like the NTSB, our desire is to determine the cause of the accident," Peetz said.

Blood tests showed Wilkerson had not been using alcohol or drugs, Leeper said.
Rayburn said Wilkerson was not using his cell phone at the time of the accident.

No charges have been filed against Wilkerson, although a criminal investigation continues.

Rayburn said fatigue was one of many factors being looked into it as the cause of the crash.

"He was driving quite a bit during those 34 hours," Rayburn said, adding that Wilkerson was making deliveries and loading and unloading his truck.

At the time of the crash, Wilkerson was driving a load of bottled water from High Springs to Jacksonville, a trip of about 85 miles.

The NTSB, using an identical school bus and truck, determined the school bus should have been visible for about 3,000 feet (more than half a mile) and there was some light skid marks before hitting the car and pushing it into the school bus.

The car burst into flames, killing all seven children, and forcing it under the school bus, with nine children aboard.  Two children remain at Shands hospital in Gainesville on Friday in serious condition.

When asked when Wilkerson saw the bus, Rayburn said, "I don't know that he did."

Rayburn said both the bus driver, Lillie Godbolt, and the truck driver had valid commercial licenses.  He noted that the driver of the car, Nikki Mann, was only 15, and had only a learners permit.  She was talking on her cell phone when the truck hit the back of her car.

Sheriff Jerry Whitehead said the crash was not Nikki Mann's fault.

"Accidents happen.  This was a tragedy.  I don't believe Nikki was at fault at all.  The truck driver...plowed into them and killed them.

Rayburn said there were no mechanical problems with any of the vehicles involved and a recorder on the truck did not show the impact.  Investigators don't know if a dog riding in Wilkerson's truck played any part in the collision.

The NTSB investigation is expected to take about a year, while the Florida Highway Patrol said it's criminal probe will take a matter of weeks.

This tiny Union County town has been in mourning since the crash last week.

On Monday, the four children of Terry and Barbara Mann were buried after a service at the First Christian Church in Lake Butler. 

They were Cynthia Nicole "Nikki" Mann, 15, who was Terry Mann's biological daughter, and adopted children Elizabeth 15, Johnny, 13, and Heaven, 3.
20 month old Anthony Lamb, who the Mann's were in the process of adopting,
was remembered in services Thursday.

The couple's nieces, Ashley Keen, 13, and Miranda Finn, were buried in Hawthorne on Wednesday, next to the body of William Edwin Scott, 70, the grandfather of the seven children, who died of a heart attack after hearing about the accident.
An Overwhelming Loss   - Posted by Laura Ingle     January 31, 2006

I have been in Lake Butler and Jacksonville, Florida to bring you the details of one of the most horrific traffic accidents I have ever reported on.  Last week, seven children were killed and several more were seriously injured when a tractor-trailer slammed into a car and school bus on a two-lane highway in Lake Butler.  I had heard about the crash while covering another story in Titusville, Florida.  I was in my rental car listening to the radio, when the words cut through the car speaker -- "Seven children are confirmed dead...and it appears they are all from the same family."  It took several hours to drive to the scene the next day, and all that time in the car I couldn't stop thinking about the family.

How could you ever handle that kind of loss?  Then I listened to more news radio reports in the car, and heard that the children's grandfather collapsed and died of a heart attack after hearing the news of the crash.  What an unbelievable loss.  What an unimaginable tidal wave of pain for this family.

Cynthia "Nikki" Mann was behind the wheel when the accident occurred and she was just 15 years old.  She was driving her adopted brothers and sisters -- one of them was just 20-months-old -- from school to the Mann family home.  Nikki only had her driver's permit, and by law is supposed to have someone over the age of 18 with her while driving.  It probably would not have made a difference, as you can see by the wreckage.  Her car was rear-ended by a massive tractor-trailer as she sat behind a stopped school bus on Florida Highway 121.  Her car was crushed and burned under the wheels of the big rig, as the massive truck plowed through her car into the back of a school bus that was unloading several children.  The bus was pushed 150 feet from where it had been stopped and rotated clockwise.  All the vehicles involved went off the highway and into the woods.

                                                                          From: GERALDO AT LARGE
                                                                                      Website

Sign InView Entries